Hello dear
Welcome To Prop's Inn
Welcome to Prop's Inn, a charming eatery located at 144 Genesee St, New Hartford, NY. This nostalgic venue specializes in hearty American fare, including their renowned Rueben sandwiches and enormous Prop Burgers. Guests rave about the friendly, attentive service that brings a personal touch to every visit. The warm, retro atmosphere is accentuated by historical photos that transport you back in time. Whether it’s the delicious pulled pork, tasty tater tots, or the inviting vibes created by skilled bartenders, Prop's Inn promises a delightful dining experience that keeps patrons returning for more. Come for the food, stay for the memories!
About
Prop's Inn
Step into the charming world of Prop's Inn, an inviting haven located at 144 Genesee St, New Hartford, NY. This delightful eatery pays homage to the nostalgia of yesteryears while serving up mouthwatering dishes that are sure to please even the most discerning palate. With a phone call away at +1 315-797-9806, you can easily plan your visit to this treasured spot.
Step inside, and the atmosphere transports you back in time. The decor is steeped in history, adorned with fascinating pictures that tell the story of the place. Customers rave about the ambiance, describing it as "so cool" and "fun," which sets the perfect backdrop for enjoying delectable meals.
The culinary stars of the show include the famous Rueben sandwiches, hailed by local patrons, like Carla Shepherd, as "amazing." Each bite delivers a perfect balance of flavors that keep you coming back for more. For burger lovers, the Prop Burger is an enormous delight, while the pulled pork is nothing short of outstanding according to Cathy Sommers. And no visit is complete without indulging in their crispy tater tots—a favorite amongst many!
What truly sets Prop's Inn apart is the exceptional service. As Marion noted, the staff goes above and beyond to ensure every customer feels valued and has everything they need for a great dining experience. The friendly bartenders also enhance the warm atmosphere, allowing guests to unwind and enjoy their meals.
Whether it’s the flavorful dishes or the nostalgic ambiance that draws you in, one thing is clear: Prop's Inn never disappoints. With every visit, you’re promised not just a meal but an experience steeped in warmth, history, and culinary delight. Make sure to stop by Prop's Inn for an unforgettable dining adventure!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ A fun old-fashioned place with amazing Rueben sandwiches!! ”
“ The food was amazing. Our waitress was the sweetest little blonde who was so nice. I am non verbal, she took her time to make sure I had what I needed and wanted. The atmosphere will take you back in time . So cool. Very clean. We will be back for sure . ”
“ This was my first time here, and it didn't disappoint. It was a cool place. I liked the pictures on the wall explaining the history of the place. The food was good and the service was as well. I will definitely visit this place again. ”
“ Prop Burger was HUGE! Hubby loves the tater tots! Pulled Pork outstanding. My favorite, along with the coleslaw! ”
“ Props never disappoints! Great bartenders...atmosphere..and food...just love it there! ”
“ Good fish fry and sides. Typical bar atmosphere. Overall it was worth the stop. Server was super and attentive. ”
“ Haven't been there in over 15 years. Came with my family and had such a wonderful experience. The food was amazing, service top notch and friendly and the price was just right. We will be making this a regular stop for a family bite out. ”
“ Service was super personable, they always are down to just have a conversation. Environment was lively. Food was delicious: they don't have a big menu, but what they do have is made to perfection with the love & care you only get at a local spot ”