Prop's Inn Menu

Welcome to Prop's Inn, a charming eatery located at 144 Genesee St, New Hartford, NY! This nostalgic venue captures the essence of classic dining with a menu that excites the palate.

• Signature Dishes: Renowned for their Rueben sandwiches, Prop's Inn delivers hearty flavors that greet you with every bite. The generous Prop Burger leaves diners raving about its sizable portions.
• Comfort Food: Enjoy savory pulled pork, paired wonderfully with fresh coleslaw, while the addictive tater tots keep patrons coming back for more.
• Inviting Atmosphere: Step into a space that transports you to another era, showcasing historical pictures and a friendly vibe, making every visit special.

With attentive service and a warm setting, Prop's Inn stands as a beloved fixture in New Hartford, promising delightful experiences and memorable meals.